How to Eat an Elephant: Rehearsing in Small, Musical Bites


When I was a young music teacher, I wanted my students to sound great now. I’d dive right into a new piece, eager to hear it from beginning to end, thinking that if we could just play through it, we’d somehow figure it out. Of course, what usually followed was a mess of notes, confused faces, and frustration on both sides of the podium. During my student teaching, my cooperating teacher gave me advice that completely changed the way I think about rehearsal. He said:

"Don't be afraid to take the music one measure at a time."


At the time, it felt almost too simple. But the longer I’ve taught, the more I’ve realized how much truth there is in that statement. You really do eat an elephant one bite at a time—and you rehearse music the same way.


The Power of Small Chunks
Trying to fix everything at once is overwhelming—for you and your students. Instead, focus on small, clearly defined sections. That might mean two measures, a single rhythm, or even a tricky fingering pattern. When students can focus on one musical challenge and master it, they build both skill and confidence. Success becomes tangible. Every small victory is a step toward musical excellence, and over time those steps add up to something remarkable.


How to Structure “Bite-Sized” Rehearsals
Here’s a simple approach I often share with new teachers:


Identify the musical “bite.” Pinpoint the exact section that’s causing trouble—measure numbers, rhythms, or even one problematic note transition. Don’t say, “Let’s fix this page.” Say, “Let’s start with these two bars.”


Define the goal. What do you want to fix? Is it tone, pitch accuracy, balance, or rhythm? Make it specific so students know what success looks like.


Loop and layer. Repeat that small section until it’s solid, then add the next layer—dynamics, phrasing, articulation. Avoid adding everything at once.


Connect the chunks. Once each section is mastered, link them together like puzzle pieces. Suddenly, that difficult passage feels easy.


Celebrate progress. Students need to feel their improvement. Point it out! “Remember how rough this was yesterday? Listen now.” That kind of feedback motivates like nothing else.




But Isn’t This Just Rote Teaching?

Some might look at this approach—isolating measures, repeating phrases—and think it’s “rote teaching.” But that couldn’t be further from the truth.


Working in small chunks is pedagogically sound because it mirrors how students learn best: through focused repetition, immediate feedback, and gradual transfer of knowledge. When done thoughtfully, this process develops understanding, not mimicry.


You’re not asking students to copy; you’re helping them discover. By rehearsing a measure at a time, they:

  1. Internalize patterns of rhythm and pitch that reappear later.
  2. Connect sound to theory, recognizing intervals, scales, and harmonic movement. 
  3. Develop muscle memory that supports expressive playing.
  4. Experience success early and often, building motivation and confidence.


This method also aligns beautifully with modern learning theories—constructivism, deliberate practice, and spiral learning—each emphasizing small, meaningful steps toward mastery. So no, it’s not rote. It’s intentional teaching—helping students understand why the music works, not just how to play it.



Why This Works


Working in small sections builds musicianship in a way that “run-throughs” can’t. It develops attention to detail, strengthens ensemble listening, and reinforces habits of excellence. And beyond musicianship, it teaches something even more valuable: how to break down big problems into manageable steps. Whether your students pursue music or not, that mindset will serve them for life.




The Takeaway

When your ensemble feels stuck, remember the wisdom of my cooperating teacher: “Don’t be afraid to take the music one measure at a time.” No one eats the elephant in one bite. Rehearse small. Rehearse smart. And before long, you’ll look back and realize that those tiny chunks turned into a polished, confident, and musical performance







0/Post a Comment/Comments